Shutap
guidesfunniestpricing

How to keep a comedy notebook: one premise page, from first note to stage

A comedy notebook works when every premise gets its own page: the exact thing you noticed at the top, the angle under it, the bit in five lines, extra tags below, and marks from every set it's been in. You cross out the lines that died instead of erasing them, rewrite them on the same page, and a bit only moves to your set list after it gets the same laugh twice.

Your turn — write yours.

free · no sign-in to start · your lines stay word for word
names get removed
checks as you type:○ who’s in it○ what someone said○ what happened after○ how it ended
audience
voice
length
wild
1 true to your story · 5 goes wild

free · no sign-in to start · names removed before anything is saved · nobody at shutap reads it · your lines stay word for word

What a comedy notebook is for

A comedy notebook isn't a place to store finished jokes. It's where half-ideas wait until you know what's funny about them, and where you keep score after every set. The comic interviewed on the Funny How Substack describes the usual path: catch something in a notebook or the Notes app the moment it feels fresh, flesh it out later, and try it on stage if it has potential. Most of those notes never become jokes, and that's normal. The ones that do usually take weeks or months of chipping away. A good notebook makes that chipping visible, so you can see what a bit used to be and why you changed it.

Write down the specific thing, not the joke

When something strikes you, write the exact words, object or moment, not your summary of it. A summary is already dead by the time you read it back. Weak note: "Smart thermostats are annoying." Better note: "The thermostat app says it 'learned my schedule.'" The second one has a quote in it, a real object and a claim you can push on. You don't need the punchline yet. You need enough detail that, two weeks from now on the train, you can still see the screen and hear the phrase. If someone said it out loud, put it in quotation marks. If it was something you saw, write the noun you'd point at.

One premise per page, laid out the same way

Give every premise its own page, or its own note on your phone, and lay each one out the same way so you can flip to any bit and know where things are. Top line: the date and the raw note, word for word. Second line: the angle, which is your opinion about the thing in one sentence. Then the bit in five lines: hook, setup, tag, tag, button. Leave the bottom third empty. That's where spare tags go, and where the marks from each set go later. For the example on this page, the angle under the thermostat note is short: "It learned I don't have a schedule." That sentence is what the whole bit has to prove.

The page as it went to the open mic

Here's the bit as first written on the thermostat page. Hook: "My new thermostat says it learns your schedule. Three weeks in, it's learned I don't have one." Setup: "It's supposed to warm the apartment right before I get home. Now it just keeps the heat on all day, in case." Tag: "Last Tuesday it sent me a notification. Just: 'Are you okay?'" Tag: "It has an eco mode called Away. It's never used it." Button: "It's the first thing in this apartment that's ever waited up for me." Under the bit, three spare tags that didn't make the cut yet, including "It started heating the place at 3 a.m. because that's when it sees me most."

Stack more tags under the bit than you'll use

The space under the bit is a tag bank. Every time you reread the page, add one more line that pushes the same idea further, without restarting the story. Most will be weak. That's fine, they're cheap. Weak spare tag: "It also tracks the humidity, which is a lot." Funnier spare tag: "It started heating the place at 3 a.m. because that's when it sees me most." The first one adds a fact. The second adds a picture you can see, and it's still about the same thing: a machine that has studied your life and drawn conclusions. When a tag in the bit dies on stage, you won't be rewriting from scratch. You'll have three candidates waiting right below it.

After the set: mark every line, cross out with one stroke

Do this the same night, or the next morning, from your recording. Go line by line and mark each one: a check for a real laugh, a tilde for a chuckle, an X for silence. Write the date of the set next to the marks so a page can hold several nights. At the thermostat bit's first mic, the hook got a chuckle, the setup was quiet as it should be, "Are you okay?" got the biggest laugh of the bit, the eco mode tag got nothing, and the button got a chuckle. Cross out the dead tag with a single line, never a scribble. You want to read it later and remember exactly what didn't work.

Rewrite on the same page, and move the biggest laugh last

Fix the dead line under its crossed-out version, not in a new note. The eco mode tag died because it explains a setting and gives the room nothing to see. Weak: "It has an eco mode called Away. It's never used it." Funnier: "There's a setting called Away. It's grayed out, like a feature for people with plans." Then look at where the biggest laugh sat. "Are you okay?" got the loudest reaction but came third, so the bit peaked early and the button had to follow it. Weak button: "It's the first thing in this apartment that's ever waited up for me." Funnier button: "Last Tuesday it sent me a notification. Just: 'Are you okay?'" The old button goes back into the tag bank.

The whole page after two mics

This is the thermostat bit as it reads now, after two open mics. Hook: "My new thermostat says it learns your schedule. Three weeks in, it's learned I don't have one." Setup: "It's supposed to warm the apartment right before I get home. Now it just keeps the heat on all day, in case." Tag: "There's a setting called Away. It's grayed out, like a feature for people with plans." Tag: "It started heating the place at 3 a.m. because that's when it sees me most." Button: "Last Tuesday it sent me a notification. Just: 'Are you okay?'" Two new marks sit next to it from the second mic: checks on both tags and the button. Every crossed-out line from the first night is still on the page above it.

Sort pages by status, and never delete

Once you have more than a dozen premise pages you need a way to find them. Alun Cochrane, a UK stand-up who has kept comedy notebooks for decades, now uses one phone note with new ideas at the top, then a Good Stuff section, then Old Stuff he doesn't delete. A folder of three tabs does the same on paper: new, working, in the set. Tom Crowl at Maher Studios describes Ken Groves's approach: he sorts by topic, first in tabbed folders and later in a spreadsheet, so one search pulls every joke on a subject. Pick whichever you'll keep up with. The rule that matters is the one Cochrane follows: dead material stays, because an old tag often fits a new premise.

From notebook to stage: when a bit graduates

A bit leaves the working pile when it gets the same laugh in the same place on two different nights, in front of strangers. Copy it then to a set list page, with its running time and the line that gets the biggest laugh, so you can build a five later without flipping through drafts. Shutap, the humor amplifier from the Shutap Humor Amplifier Lab, uses the same five-line page. In Shutap Bits it cuts what you tell it into a hook, setup, two tags and a button, keeping your words word for word. It drafts only the lines your story left out, marked so you can change or delete them. Tap funnier on a line that died for three other ways to say it, yours listed first, lock what works and rehearse on the teleprompter. The notebook, the marks and the calls stay yours.

The techniques, as Shutap uses them

Each move on this page is in the humor amplifier's technique bank: when you tap funnier on a line, one of these may be the shape of the options you get.

Promote the biggest laugh to the button

A bit that peaks in the middle makes everything after it feel like a letdown; ending on the biggest laugh gives the room a clean place to stop.

Last Tuesday it sent me a notification. Just: 'Are you okay?'

Try it: Mark which line got the biggest laugh at your last set; if it isn't the last line, move it there and cut or bank whatever used to follow it.

Quote the machine's own words

Flat, official wording dropped into a sad human moment does the joke on its own, and the audience recognizes the tone from their own phones.

There's a setting called Away. It's grayed out, like a feature for people with plans.

Try it: Find a label, message or setting name on a device in your bit and put it in the line word for word, then say one short thing about it.

Questions people ask

How do comedians keep track of their jokes?

Most keep a notebook or a phone note where each premise gets its own page or section. They mark every line after a set, cross out what died, rewrite it underneath, and copy bits that work twice into a separate set list.

Should I use a paper notebook or my phone for comedy?

Use whichever you'll actually open. A phone note is always with you and searchable; paper makes crossed-out lines easy to keep and read. Many comics capture on the phone, then copy promising notes onto a premise page later.

What should I write in a comedy notebook?

The exact thing you noticed, in the words you heard or saw, then your angle on it in one sentence, then the bit as hook, setup, two tags and a button. Below that, spare tags and the marks from every set the bit has been in.

How do I know when a joke is ready for my set?

When it gets the same laugh in the same spot on two different nights in front of strangers. One good night can be the room. Once it repeats, move it to your set list page with its running time.

Should I throw away jokes that bombed?

No. Cross them out with a single line so you can still read them, and keep the page. A tag that died in one bit often works in another premise months later, and the old version shows you what you already tried.

Sources

Write your bit. Funnier only where you ask. →

Try it on your own material.

Type what happened, in your words; tap funnier where you’re stuck. Get the video, stand-up with delivery cues, sketch and skit. Free: 3 bits, downloads unlimited with the shutap.com mark.

Say it funnier ↑

SHUTAP. Say it funnier.

Fazier badgeFeatured on LaunchNestFeatured on MegaLaunchFeatured on PostYourStartuplisted inThe AI DirectoryVerified on DANG!