How to make a joke funnier, one line at a time
To make a joke funnier, rewrite it one line at a time and give every line one job: the hook names a contradiction, the setup plants facts without giving away the turn, each tag adds new proof, and the button ends on the laugh word. Most jokes aren't missing an idea. They're carrying lines that explain, summarize or keep talking after the laugh.
Your turn — write yours.
free · no sign-in to start · your lines stay word for wordfree · no sign-in to start · names removed before anything is saved · nobody at shutap reads it · your lines stay word for word
The bit as first written
Here is a real-sounding first draft, the kind that goes in the notebook the night you think of it. Hook: "I bought a standing desk to be healthier." Setup: "I've had it three months and I mostly sit at it." Tag: "So it's basically a really expensive regular desk." Tag: "Sometimes I raise it just to feel something." Button: "So yeah, I guess I'm not a standing desk person, which is funny." The premise is fine. Spending money on a better version of yourself and then not using it is relatable. The problem is that every line tells the audience the joke instead of letting them catch it.
Find the line that carries nothing
Read the bit out loud, slowly, and write one word next to each line saying what it does. In the draft above you get: intention, confession, summary, shrug, apology. Only one of those is a joke. MasterClass's writing tips land in the same place: rewrite more than once, read it aloud for cadence and cut the wordiness. A line that only restates the line before it is the first to go. A line that explains why something is funny is the second. Circle the worst one and fix that before touching anything else, because a bad setup can make a good button look dead.
Hook: say the contradiction first
A hook is the first thing out of your mouth, and on a video it's the first two seconds. "I bought a standing desk to be healthier" is an intention, and intentions are polite. Put the cost and the absurd part in the same sentence instead. Weak: "I bought a standing desk to be healthier." Funnier: "I paid eight hundred dollars to stand up at work." Now the hook has a number you can see and a goal that sounds silly once it has a price on it. The audience leans in because they can already tell how this ends, and they want to watch you get there.
Setup: plant facts, hide the turn
The draft's setup gives the whole joke away: "I mostly sit at it." Once that's said, the tags have nothing left to reveal. A setup should hand over specific, harmless details and keep the turn for later. Weak: "I've had it three months and I mostly sit at it." Funnier: "It has a motor, a little screen that counts how long you've been standing, and three saved heights." Nothing in that line is a joke yet. It's a list of features, said proudly. But it plants two things the next lines will pay off, the screen and the saved heights, and it points the audience the wrong way: it sounds like you love this desk.
First tag: show the proof, not the verdict
"It's basically a really expensive regular desk" is a verdict. You reached the conclusion for the audience, so they have nothing to do. Give them the evidence and let them reach it themselves, one beat behind you. Weak: "So it's basically a really expensive regular desk." Funnier: "The screen says zero. It has said zero since March." The tag uses a detail from the setup, the counter, and adds one new fact, the month. Saying "zero" twice is the joke: the second time is flatter and longer, like you've stopped arguing with it. Tags work when each one adds something the last line didn't.
Second tag: hand the job to an object
"Sometimes I raise it just to feel something" is a phrase people already say about a lot of things, so it lands as filler. Change the shape of the second tag so it doesn't repeat the first one's rhythm. A good move here is to give the job you failed at to something else in the room. Weak: "Sometimes I raise it just to feel something." Funnier: "Once a week I raise it all the way up so my coffee can stand. Somebody in this house should." The coffee gets the standing desk. You get the chair. The second sentence is four words and lands on "should," which is where the guilt is.
Button: end on the laugh word, then stop
Three apologies are packed into the draft's button: "So yeah, I guess I'm not a standing desk person, which is funny." Telling people it was funny is the surest way to end a bit on silence. The button should be the hardest-hitting line, with the word that triggers the laugh in the final position and nothing after it. Weak: "So yeah, I guess I'm not a standing desk person, which is funny." Funnier: "Last night I checked the three saved heights. Two of them are sitting." It calls back to the setup, it's short, and "sitting" is the last word. Say it, then close your mouth.
The whole bit, after
Hook: "I paid eight hundred dollars to stand up at work." Setup: "It has a motor, a little screen that counts how long you've been standing, and three saved heights." Tag: "The screen says zero. It has said zero since March." Tag: "Once a week I raise it all the way up so my coffee can stand. Somebody in this house should." Button: "Last night I checked the three saved heights. Two of them are sitting." Same story, same desk, same person. The jokes still aim at the comic's own choices, not at anyone else. What changed is that every line now has one job, two details from the setup get paid off later, and there are no words after the last laugh.
Test it, then fix the line that went quiet
A page can't tell you which line works. A room can. Backstage's joke-writing guide ends the same way: try it on friends or strangers, then perform it, on tape or at a local show. At an open mic, record the set on your phone and listen back the next morning with the notebook open. Put a check next to every line that got a laugh and a dash next to every line that got nothing. Rewrite only the dashes. If the button dies but both tags hit, the button is probably saying too much. If nothing hits, go back to the setup and see whether it gave the turn away.
Using Shutap on one stubborn line
Shutap, the humor amplifier from the Shutap Humor Amplifier Lab, uses this same five-line notebook. In Shutap Bits you write the hook, setup, two tags and button in your own words. When one line won't get funnier, tap funnier on that line only and you get three other ways to say it, built from the lines you wrote, with your version listed first. Lock the lines that are done so nothing touches them. You pick, cut and rewrite, and the bit stays yours. Then you can post it as a five-second video or rehearse it on the teleprompter.
The techniques, as Shutap uses them
Each move on this page is in the humor amplifier's technique bank: when you tap funnier on a line, one of these may be the shape of the options you get.
Open on what it cost you
A number makes the choice visible, and a goal said next to its price shows the contradiction before any joke is told.
I paid eight hundred dollars to stand up at work.
Try it: Rewrite your hook so the cost, in money, time or pride, sits in the same sentence as what you hoped to get.
Setup with no spoilers
When the setup sounds sincere, the audience is pointed the wrong way, so the tags have something left to reveal.
It has a motor, a little screen that counts how long you've been standing, and three saved heights.
Try it: Delete any word in your setup that tells how the story ends, and add two concrete details you can use again.
Evidence over summary
People laugh harder at a conclusion they arrive at one beat after you than at one you hand them.
The screen says zero. It has said zero since March.
Try it: Find a tag that starts with "basically" or "so it's" and replace it with one observable detail and a date or count.
The object picks up the slack
The object succeeding where you didn't makes the failure visual, and the short follow-up lands the guilt.
Once a week I raise it all the way up so my coffee can stand. Somebody in this house should.
Try it: Name the thing you didn't do, give it to a cup, a plant or a pet, and add a four-word line about who should be doing it.
Cut everything after the laugh
Words after the laugh word give the audience a reason to wait instead of laughing, and the laugh drains out.
Last night I checked the three saved heights. Two of them are sitting.
Try it: Underline the word in your button that makes it funny, move it to the end, and delete everything that follows it.
Questions people ask
How do I make my joke funnier without changing what it's about?
Keep the premise and rewrite the lines around it. Make the hook name the contradiction, take the reveal out of the setup, turn summary tags into specific evidence, and end the button on the laugh word with nothing after it.
Why does my joke get no laugh even though the idea is funny?
Usually a line is explaining the joke. A setup that gives away the turn, a tag that states the conclusion, or a button that adds "which is funny" all leave the audience nothing to figure out, so they smile and wait.
What does punching up a joke mean?
Punching up means rewriting a joke that already exists to get bigger or more laughs, usually by sharpening specific words, cutting extra ones and adding tags. It works on one line at a time rather than starting the whole bit over.
Should the funny word go at the end of a joke?
Yes, in most jokes. Put the word that turns the line in the final position and cut anything after it. In "Two of them are sitting," the laugh lives in "sitting," so the sentence stops there.
How many times should I rewrite a joke?
Until every line has one job and nothing repeats. Then test it in front of people, mark which lines got laughs, and rewrite only the ones that went quiet. Many bits take several open mics to settle.
Sources
Write your bit. AI fills only the gaps. →
Try it on what you want to say.
Type what happened, in your words; tap funnier where you’re stuck. Get the video, stand-up with delivery cues, sketch and skit. Free: 3 bits, downloads unlimited with the shutap.com mark.
